Subscribe to The Y’ all– an once a week send off regarding individuals, locations and plans specifying Texas, generated by Texas Tribune reporters staying in neighborhoods throughout the state.
TRINIDAD– It was a chilly early morning in February 2022 when Bud Morton drove his black 2015 Chevrolet vehicle down the last mile of Ranch to Market Roadway 1667 to the very same launch factor he had actually made use of to reach his preferred angling place for greater than twenty years.
There, on a creek called the Cutoff, he would certainly learnt more about all the various sorts of fish and their spawning timetables. He invested years checking out with alligator gar swimming along with his watercraft and crawlers capturing a trip as he browsed his method with the river’s boxcar culverts and under wood bridges.
However this moment, when he brought up, he saw 2 5-foot-high, red pipeline fencings obstructing the water’s side. Indications hung from the fencings: “NO TRESPASSING.”
Frustrated and confused, Morton took his Jonny watercraft and left.
” I was absolutely crazy,” Morton stated. “As the week or more afterwards took place, a lot more fencings were constructed and even more dust generated.”
The end of that single-lane state roadway was the area’s last continuing to be public watercraft launch to access the tiny streams that twist with southwestern Henderson Region.
It was Phillip Surls, a rich regional business owner, that set up the fencings after he acquired the residential or commercial property along each side of FM 1667 in late 2021. He wished to maintain his livestock off the roadway, his lawyer has actually stated.
Surls, that decreased to be talked to for this write-up, has actually been consistently informed to eliminate the fencing by the state, and he’s been reprimanded for excavating up the creek by Henderson Region and the United State Military Corps of Engineers. He was fined by Texas Parks and Wild animals for eliminating hundreds of mussels in doing this job.
However fruitless. Surls remains to suggest that land bordering the Cutoff is not public– that it comes from him and he is well within his civil liberties to limit accessibility.
His relocate to obstruct his next-door neighbors from the river has actually triggered a collection of lawful fights over land and water public accessibility concerns that have actually played out for several years.
In September, Surls racked up a significant success when an area court ruled the Cutoff is not accessible, implying it’s not a public river. And if it’s not a public river, after that the general public does not require accessibility to it.
The court’s judgment was a strike to a team of area participants that invested years fundraising to pay for a lawyer going to handle this battle. Their sources hardly covered a fifth of the lawful charges they have actually accumulated. However they intend to appeal the judgment.
Those residents, that developed a team called Conserve the Cutoff, state they’re being outgunned by a person with even more cash and political links that eliminated their accessibility to a vital part of their area’s identification.
“What harmed my sensations one of the most? That was our little area heaven,” stated Elden Reschke, a participant of the team that can count the variety of times he’s left East Texas on one hand. “And an abundant male’s taking it far from us.”
The lengthy battle to maintain the Cutoff public
In the late 1800s, Dallas manufacturers had a hard time to obtain watercrafts up the Trinity River since its water degrees were unstable and usually laden with blockages, like downed trees, or doglegs that were tough to browse. They supported for significant modifications to the river’s location. Throughout years, a brand-new course for the Trinity was taken, with the financial investment of numerous bucks and the setup of brand-new dams.
Thus, the Cutoff was developed– called since it was essentially removed from the Trinity River. And for the following century, residents would certainly combat to maintain it open up to the general public.
Today, the Cutoff is a 12-mile stream along the boundary of Henderson and Navarro areas. It begins at the Old Cedar Creek, and finishes at Creslenn Cattle ranch Lake. It goes through tiny woody locations and cattle ranch lands. Personal lakes have actually developed along each side of the river.
In 1931, in a tale that parallels Surls’, Adam Cone, a business owner from a close-by community, bought land bordering the Cutoff and attempted to obstruct the general public from it. His activities triggered area outrage and caused the problem being occupied in an unique session of that year’s Legislature.
Texas legislators passed a legislation that year, proclaiming the Cutoff public and requiring that Henderson Region and the Texas Division of Transport develop roadways so the area might remain to utilize it for angling and searching. Nevertheless, that legislation was rescinded in 1967, when the state combined numerous divisions under one umbrella called Texas Parks and Wild Animals.
In the 1950s, an additional regional business owner, Clyde Alexander, developed Creslenn Park, which was lots of acres along the river with barbecue tables, camping areas and anchors. He assured the area it would certainly be open to the general public to get to the water for the following half a century.
That park land is currently possessed by Surls.
However prior to it shut, it was a growing area location– a room to deep fry fresh captured catfish on the 4th of July or reduce a cake on birthday celebrations.
Now, the barbecue locations that belonged to Creslenn Park have actually rotted. Skeletal remains of old watercraft anchors stand out of the water.
Lee Nolan, 76, stated he feels bitter the truth that the area can not utilize the park currently as it when did, which also fishing on the Cutoff has actually been removed.
He stated he matured mosting likely to Cresslen Park. When he was a youngster, he and his papa would certainly go see his excellent uncle that stayed in among the homes around the park where they would certainly play cards and dominos at the barbecue tables.
As he got older, he invested several nights camping there with his close friends. One evening, the weeps of a hill lion discouraged them so severely they concealed in their resting bags, he remembered.
” It was a wonderful location to mature,” Nolan stated. “Trinidad was a wonderful community to mature in. And Cresslen Park, or the Cutoff– as we passionately called it– was home entertainment for several, years.”
Phillip Surls’ fight
Surls, 58, matured in Henderson Region and he still lives and runs a livestock procedure and a building and construction business there.
In 2021, he acquired big swathes of the land bordering the Cutoff right before Xmas for his livestock procedure. That land was valued at regarding $19 million this year.
Surls evidently meant to relocate his livestock from one side of the financial institutions of the Old Cedar Creek to the various other, according to a letter his lawyer contacted the united state Military Corp of Engineers. In February 2022, he began digging up, or excavating up various other locations of the creek, and laying big rocks. He prolonged a culvert and set up the fencings to have the cows. The letter from his lawyer stated the fencings were just changing fencings that were currently there.
Morton stated there was never ever a fencing like what Surls set up. There was a fencing on each side of the river, yet it was out the state right-of-way and did not obstruct public accessibility.
The area offered Surls consent to maintain the fencing, and Morton stated for some time constable’s replacements would certainly implement trespassing infractions for individuals that attempted to go across.
However the adhering to month in March, the Military Corps of Engineers sent out Surls a discontinue and desist letter claiming he had actually serviced government waters without permission from the corps. The letter claims Surls went against the Tidy Water Act when he placed dust and sand and various other product along the state’s right-of-way. He quit working.
Around the very same time, the Texas Division of Transport sent out Surls a notification that he was blocking the general public right-of-way with the fencing and he must eliminate it within thirty day.
A couple of months later on, in September of that year, TxDOT sent out Surls a 2nd letter, once more informing him to eliminate the fencing.
The fencing is still there.
Asked why TxDOT has actually taken no actions to eliminate it, an authorities stated they’re awaiting lawful issues to be solved.
” While the fencing was within the state’s right-of-way, we held back on eliminating it as a result of recurring lawful issues, consisting of a cease-and-desist order from the Corps of Engineers,” Jeff Williford, the TxDOT Tyler Area Public Details Police officer, stated. Though in TxDOT’s letter to Surls, they stated their order does not go against the Corps’ stop and desist.
Around the very same time, Surls took a brand-new passion in Texas national politics– shoveling out $23,900 on state prospects in November and December of that year.
Prior to this, he would certainly given away a total amount of $350 to government and state political teams over greater than one decade.
The biggest contributions were made to Texas Attorney general of the United States Ken Paxton– that Surls offered $10,000 to on Nov. 7– someday prior to he won reelection. He additionally offered Dawn Buckingham $5,000 on Dec. 8, a month after her political election to lead the General Land Workplace.
The General Land Workplace in 2010 provided a point of view mentioning that the waters of the Cutoff are public. However the firm hasn’t fallen to this existing issue.
The Texas Attorney general of the United States’s Workplace has the authority to take legal action against the landowner in behalf of the state companies.
TxDOT referred Surls situation to Paxton’s workplace for lawsuit. However the chief law officer’s workplace never ever sued. An agent for the chief law officer’s workplace recommended TxDOT altered its mind.
” It is not unusual for a state entity to make a recommendation and have our workplace prepare a possible activity, yet after that the referring firm demands that the workplace take a various strategy than what the reference originally asked for,” a speaker for the Workplace of the Attorney general of the United States stated in an e-mail.
By the end of 2022, residents were discouraged by a seeming absence of activity by federal government authorities. They developed the not-for-profit, Conserve the Cutoff, and took their situation to court.
Conserve the Cutoff took legal action against Henderson Region in January 2023 for deserting an area roadway that had actually when worked as an additional accessibility indicate the Cutoff that is currently being made use of as an exclusive roadway. They shed and are attracting the High court.
After that, the not-for-profit taken legal action against Surls in government court that March for breaking the Tidy Water Act by releasing products right into the river. They pointed out the Military Corps of Engineers letter. Surls’ lawyers said the job was total, so he was not proactively breaking the legislation, which suggested Conserve the Cutoff had no lawful standing to take legal action against. The government court concurred with Surls a year later on, and the fit was disregarded.
The team additionally took legal action against Surls in area court in August 2023, asking the court to state the Cutoff public and need Surls eliminate his fencings. Last month, the court agreed Surls.
On Nov. 17, 2023, after greater than a year of examining the influences of excavating up product and including it to the right-of-way, Texas Parks and Wild animals fined Surls’ business $307,895.70 for eliminating almost 7,500 mussels. That penalty had actually not been paid since mid-September 2025, according to the firm.
What’s following for the Cutoff
This year, even more authorities began exterior siding with Surls over the area.
” You reached roadway the stumbling blocks right into personal property,” claimed state Sen. Robert Nichols, R-Jacksonville. “Taxpayers are paying to keep that point … There’s the concern of, are we going to have taxpayer bucks remain to money that?”
Nichols stated Creslenn Park isn’t worth conserving, including that he believed it had actually developed into a hangout for drug addict and homeless individuals prior to it shut. While he stated he still thinks about the Cutoff public, he stated there is no factor for the area to utilize personal property to accessibility it.
Several area participants shot down Nichols’ evaluation of what that location was.
” It was never ever, ever before a mess,” stated John Shumate, a previous mayor of Malakoff and long time Henderson Region local. “Also when I was dropping there in my older years it was well maintained.”
In February 2025, Nichols and state Reps. Cody Harris and Keith Bell authored a letter to TxDOT suggesting the firm provide Surls the last mile and a quarter of FM 1667. This would certainly remove any type of need that the firm take legal action against Surls.
And last month, TxDOT asked Henderson Region if it would certainly think about approving the roadway as component of its system. The area commissioners, in a 3-2 ballot, authorized a letter revealing passion in taking control of FM 1667 on Sept. 30.
This offered the area a seat at the table to choose what will certainly occur to FM 1667 if TxDOT deserts it, Clint Davis, the area lawyer, informed The Texas Tribune.
” It is really clear that this activity in no other way obliges the Region to take obligation for the roadway or to end up being in charge of it at a later day,” he stated.
Some fret the commissioners, several of whom have actually agreed Surls on this issue, would certainly simply allow him have it.
Toward completion of August, the Military Corps of Engineers was nearing the verdict of its examination right into whether Surls job went against the Tidy Water Act and what the solution would certainly be, according to Neil Lebsock, a detective. Surls’ lawful group asked the Military Corps of Engineers to figure out whether the Cutoff is in fact waters of the united state under the brand-new interpretation bied far by the United State High Court in 2023.
Lebsock will certainly need to invest the following couple of weeks establishing whether the Cutoff attaches to the Trinity River by any means, which would certainly make it waters of the united state. If Lebsock establishes the Cutoff is not waters of the united state, after that he has no authority to pursue Surls for breaking the Tidy Water Act.
” It’s a considerable choice, if we were to make that,” Lebsock stated.
This situation is greater than almost a public angling place, residents state. They fret it might unlock for personal landowners to limit accessibility to public waters as long as they have sufficient cash to eliminate the lawful fights.
Nolan determined it was time to review his old haunt on Tuesday. He cleared out throughout of FM 1667 with his little girl and viewed vehicles relocate in and out of Surls’ residential or commercial property. Now, he had not yet gone into the battle, yet he expanded angrier as he considered exactly how unjust the scenario was.
” Maybe we can obtain it working out sufficient that we can battle this point completely to the Texas High Court,” Nolan stated. “It’s such a takeoff to have a component of Trinidad’s background being over used and suddenly altered.”
Disclosure: Chevrolet and Texas Parks And Wild Animals Division have actually been economic fans of The Texas Tribune, a not-for-profit, detached wire service that is moneyed partially by contributions from participants, structures and company enrollers. Financial fans play no function in the Tribune’s journalism. Locate a total checklist of them below.
